Brahms’s Ein Deutsches Requiem| NDR Vokalensemble, WDR Rundfunkchor| NDR Radiophilharmonie | Manze |

Repost.  I’m reposting this performance of the Brahms’s EDR — then there’s the performance at the top of the page — after hearing the New England Conservatory Chamber Singers and their wobbling and fluttering in a piece by Brahms.  Why can’t they sound like the Chorus in the performance above from Deutschland and in this performance below from Deutschland singing with perfect intonation in all voice sections?  The same goes for the Tanglewood Festival Chorus.  Why can’t they sound like these two Orchestra Choruses?  (It’s not because of James Burton).  Both of the Orchestra Choruses from Deutschland are examples of choral excellence.  One has to assume that New England Conservatory does not care about choral excellence based on how their choral ensembles sound — specifically the sopranos and altos — with their wobbling and fluttering.  Who likes that rough and ugly sound?  I think we know.  It doesn’t sound smooth, lush and velvety.  And the NEC Concert Choir sounds the same as the NEC Chamber Singers.  Because they’re prepared by the same person who doesn’t believe in perfect intonation, one of the foundations of choral excellence (and also of orchestral playing, where one has the perfect blending of all the violins, for example, the same for all the cellos, the same for all the basses, etc)?

Here’s another Brahms’s EDR I can highly recommend. The Chorus is superb, as is the Radiophilharmonie. This performance is also from Deutschland. I’m beginning to think they have the best trained Orchestra Choruses anywhere these days. This performance took place in Hannover on 11 March 2023.

This performance is different from the Brahms EDR from Frankfurt that I’ve featured for some time now. The mic’ing is different and the different sections are easier to hear. I was especially impressed with their tenor section, especially in this part beginning at 1.09.25. No weak tenors there.

I enjoyed Benjamin Appl, baritone soloist. He sang with minimal vibrato and never resorted to “screaming.” I can’t say the same about the soprano soloist. As is often the case with soprano soloists, she seemed unable to control her voice at times — what is with soprano soloists not being able to control their voice? — and she was really the loudest “instrument” on stage at that point in the score.

I recognised many of the choristers from their other performances in Frankfurt with the hr-S. And one of the flautists in this Orchestra is a new arrival as flautist in the hr-S. So she’s in both Orchestras.

All comments should be about the performance from a position of choral and orchestral excellence. No religious proselytising please, and no quoting of the text for religious purposes, por favor/please.

2 thoughts on “Brahms’s Ein Deutsches Requiem| NDR Vokalensemble, WDR Rundfunkchor| NDR Radiophilharmonie | Manze |

  1. Pingback: The Conservatory features Orchestra Choruses trained in perfect intonation and crisp diction et al: Below is choral excellence from Deutschland: Brahms’s Ein deutsches Requiem ∙ hr-Sinfonieorchester ∙ MDR-Rundfunkchor ∙ Solisten ∙ Philipp Ah

  2. Pingback: Eleven Radio Orchestras and Seven Radio Choruses | The Century of Insanity

Leave a Reply