Charles Wood – O Thou the Central Orb – St Paul’s Anglican Cathedral (London)

I thought I’d post another Anglican anthem by Charles Wood. It’s his “O Thou the Central Orb” and it was sung for The National Service of Thanksgiving to Celebrate The Diamond Jubilee Of Her Majesty The Queen in 2012. It’s performed here by the combined Choirs of St Paul’s Cathedral and Her Majesty’s Chapel Royal (those boys are in the red in the centre on each side).  They are directed by Andrew Carwood, Director of Music, St Paul’s Cathedral.  Both the Cathedral and the Chapel Royal are part of the established Church of England.

This is not an ideal performance, but the best I’ve found. The boys are of course superb singing with perfect intonation. It’s the Men of the Cathedral Choir with their heavy wobbling vibrato — especially near the end of the piece — that I have a problem with. I’m not sure why the Director of Music didn’t correct this and tell the men, “Guys, this is not opera, and we’re not an Opera Chorus, so we won’t be needing that very noticeable vibrato.” Or, there is another possibility since I’ve heard this from the men before. I’m not saying this is the case but it is possible: The Men of the Choir think they have to “over sing” to account for such a large space as the Cathedral. I’ve noticed that with some choristers, when they “over sing” or push their voice it can turn on uncontrollable noticeable vibrato. I have heard that with some choristers in other settings where they normally did not sing with any noticeable vibrato. Nevertheless, I found the men’s vibrato/wobbling annoying but tried to ignore it and listen to the superb trebles/boys instead.

St Paul’s Anglican Cathedral has one of the very few residential Choir Schools anywhere. The organ console is located up above the Quire stalls which you’ll see if you look for it.

 

Leave a Reply